Updates
Home / Current Affairs / A warning to the Facebook Shaykh and Twitter Mufti

A warning to the Facebook Shaykh and Twitter Mufti

Speaking without knowledge

Before I started studying at The Islamic University of Madeenah, I worked as a social media officer for a well-known Muslim organisation. As time progressed, I noticed a worrying trend amongst Muslims, many of whom were speaking without knowledge by answering Islamic questions and in many cases, issuing their own fatāwa.

This phenomenon is very dangerous not only for the one speaking without knowledge, but also for the one acting upon that false knowledge. Imagine if you had a medical problem, you would never consider visiting an engineer for a diagnosis, as that would not make sense at all. A medical doctor is specialised in that field, and you would, therefore, only trust a medic with your health. So why is it that we trust unqualified people with respect to our hereafter and the wellbeing of our religion?

The advent of social media brings with it many benefits such as an increased connection with the wider world and easy access to knowledge and learning. This coupled with the recent surge in learning about the religion, through institutes, weekend courses and such, a lot of people are keen to showcase their newly acquired knowledge. However, as the saying goes, with great power comes great responsibility. Among the many problems of social media is that suddenly everyone becomes a self-proclaimed scholar. Many are often very casual and careless in passing judgments and giving religious rulings.

My warning to the Facebook Shaykh, the Twitter Mufti and the Google Aalim is: be careful when answering questions and speaking about Allāh without knowledge. Allāh warns every Muslim against speaking without knowledge, as He says:

“And follow not (i.e., say not, or do not, or witness not) that of which you have no knowledge. Verily, the hearing, and the sight, and the heart of each of those ones will be questioned (by Allāh)” [1]

The great Imam, Imam Malik  [d.791h] was once approached by a man who had travelled all the way from al-Andalus to specifically meet him and ask him questions. Out of the forty questions that he asked, Imam Malik said, “lā adrī” (I don’t know) to thirty-six to thirty-eight of them. The questioner was annoyed with the responses of Imam Malik and Imam Malik told the questioner to go and announce to his people that: “Imam Malik does not know!”

In this day and age, we find the complete opposite. Everyone wants to show how much knowledge they have and be the first to answer people’s questions, regardless of whether what they are saying is correct or not. It is better to remain silent than to speak to without certain knowledge. Imam Malik said:

‘The shield of the scholar is, “I don’t know”’ [2]

Ibn al-Qayyim, the student of Shaykh al-Islām ibn Taymiyyah, said:

“The Salaf, the Sahābah and Tābi’īn, used to regard it as makrūh (disliked) to rush to issue fatwas. Each of them would wish that someone else would take care of it, but if he realised that he had no alternative but to answer, he would do his utmost to find the ruling from the Qur’ān and Sunnah or the words of the Rightly-Guided khalīfahs, then he would give his fatwa.”

‘Abd-Allāh ibn al-Mubārak said:

“Sufyān told us from Atā’ ibn al-Sā’ib from ‘Abd al-Rahmān ibn Abī Layla who said: ‘I met one hundred and twenty of the Companions of the Messenger of Allāh (peace and blessings of Allāh be upon him)’ – and I think he said, in the mosque – ‘and there was none of them who had to speak but he wished that his brother would take care of it; there was no one who had to give a fatwa but he wished that his brother would take care of it.” [3]

Ibn al Qayyim said that speaking about Allāh (‘azza wa jalla) without knowledge is the greatest sin that you could commit. [4] This is based on the following verse in the Qur’ān:

“Say: The things that my Lord has indeed forbidden are al-Fawāhishah (great evil sins, every kind of unlawful sexual intercourse, etc.), whether committed openly or secretly, sins (of all kinds), unrighteous oppression, joining partners (in worship) with Allāh for which He has given no authority and saying things about Allāh of which you have no knowledge.” [5]

In discussing this verse in his momentous work, Madārij al-Sālikīn, Ibn al-Qayyim says that Allāh first mentions al-fawāhishah and this is the least of the sins that Allāh mentions. Thereafter, Allāh mentions the sins that transgress against the truth; this is a greater sin than the first one that Allāh mentioned. Next, Allāh mentions making shirk with Him, and finally He mentions saying things about Allāh of which you have no knowledge. Ibn al-Qayyim explains that Allāh is going from the lesser of the sins to the greater.

Speaking about Allāh does not always mean speaking about Him directly. Speaking without knowledge involves: ascribing something falsely to Allāh, changing or altering the religion of Allāh, denying what He has confirmed or confirming what He has denied, supporting something that Allāh opposes, liking something that Allāh dislikes or disliking something that Allāh likes. It is also amongst the root causes of all bid’ah and shirk.

In other words, when you are speaking without knowledge, in the religion, then in fact you are changing the religion of Allāh. Allāh says in Sūrah al-Nahl:

“And do not say about what your tongues assert of untruth, ‘This is lawful and this is unlawful,’ to invent falsehood about Allāh. Indeed, those who invent falsehood about Allāh will not succeed.” [6]

Appearing knowledgeable or ‘knowing’ all the answers may increase your standing in front of people but imagine standing in front of Allāh having spoken about Him without knowledge.

So what can we do to solve this problem? The solution is to return to the people of knowledge and to not speak without knowledge. There are plenty of scholars and students of knowledge on social media who are able to answer questions. As Allāh says:

“And We sent not before you, [O Muhammad], except men to whom We revealed [the message], so ask the people of knowledge if you do not know.” [7]

If you cannot refer back to a person of knowledge or do not know the answer, simply do not answer it. The scholars agree that half of knowledge is knowing when to say: “I don’t know.

Source: www.islam21.com

Notes:

[1] Al-Qur’ān 17:36
[2] Yusuf Ibn ‘Abd al-Barr in his al-Intiqa’ fi Fada’il al-Thalatha al-Fuqaha
[3] I’lām al-Muwaqqi’īn, 1/28, 29
[4] Madārij al-Sālikīn
[5] Al-Qur’ān 7:33
[6] Al-Qur’ān 16:116
[7] Al-Qur’ān 16:43

About Abu Muslim Kamran

Abu Muslim Kamran is a webmaster for Islam21c. He has been actively involved with many international dawah organisations and Islamic websites, as well as owning his own web design agency. Having previously studied in Egypt, he is currently a student at the Islamic University of Madeenah.

9 comments

  1. Asalam wa alakum wara’matulihe wa a’barakatu aboo kamran wallahi your article has been absolutely beneficial may allah reward you for words that you used. You have made it really clear and effective how severe it is to speak without knowledge it has spoken to me and hit me in the heart and opened my eyes and your dilvery is effective truthful powerful funny and clear without being harsh. Allahhumma barik lahu. Keep up writing and may allah reward you and put barakah into all that you do. And may allah reward you your family and this entire ummah in this life and the next and make us all the inheritors of the paradise of delight inshallah and also make us amongst those who will be successful radiant and blessed with happiness on the last. Jazakallah khaire and Asalam wa alakum wara’matulihe wa a’barakatu akhi.

  2. Jazakallah khier ya Abu Muslim (Abu Isa), a great reminder and article mashallah tabarakallah. May Allah increase you in wisdom.

  3. Samy Merchant

    “Imagine if you had a medical problem, you would never consider visiting an engineer for a diagnosis, as that would not make sense at all. A medical doctor is specialised in that field, and you would, therefore, only trust a medic with your health. So why is it that we trust unqualified people with respect to our hereafter and the wellbeing of our religion?”

    The analogy above is not entirely accurate. We do not have a “religion” like the Christians, Jews, Bhuddists, Hindus etc. We have a DEEN (The DEEN of Islam) which covers worldy aspects as well. So, obviously I cannot trust my affairs with a person who has mastered our “religion” but not our DEEN. The Islamic students of the past did not go to the middle of a desert to study their DEEN. They went to city centers, working and studying there. And how can I trust my hereafter with a “Shaykh” who does not have the intelligence to realize that one does not wear an Arabic “thowb” in the West, in the 21st century at that!

  4. Samy Merchant

    Medina University muftis are more concerned about the intricacies of grave worship and moon sighting, the specifics of why celebrating the Mawlid is an innovation and whether the 2021 multi-billion dollar mission by the United Arab Emitates to Mars is haram, bidah, mukrooh, mubah or mandoob.

    Consequently, and very unfortunately, normal Muslims have no choice but to turn to facebook, twitter and google muftis.

    • Mawlid is related to deen due to the misplaced belief that one will get reward by doing it. UAE sending their Mars mission off has no reward associated with it, hence you cannot bring it into the realm of deem as such.
      there is no excuse for ignorance.

  5. So this is where you landed up K@M, I knew about your rabbit escapade in egypt but didn’t know you went off to madeenah to study.

  6. Masha’Allah, an excellent article. Something all Muslims need to hear, especially these days.

  7. A very timely reminder required and well written. But a question i would like to put forward, is it ok to post authentic Hadith after verifying the source and posting the source of the hadith along with the hadith or article?

    • Abu Muslim Kamran

      barakAllaahu feek. The issue is more about speaking on matters or giving answers without knowledge rather than sharing knowledge.

      Sharing authentic ayaats/ahadeeth/athaar (especially with references) is beneficial inshaAllaah and comes under the heading of “helping each other in birr and taqwa”.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

Verify *

DON'T MISS OUT!
Subscribe To Newsletter
Be the first to get latest updates and exclusive content straight to your email inbox.
Stay Updated
Give it a try, you can unsubscribe anytime.
close-link
Subscribe for Updates or Support Us