In the latest attempt at unabashed apologism, some Muslim groups have asked Muslim women to don a ‘Poppy Hijab’ in order to remember the Muslim soldiers that took part in the two world wars. The president of one organisation suggested that these hijabs would “take attention away from extremists.“ [1] This latest gimmick has got to be the most ill-conceived of the recent spate of “we are not extremists” initiatives.
Marketing the poppy as a stance against extremism suggests that refusing the symbol is tantamount to ‘extremism’. A great selling point right there. Buy a £22 hijab to prove that you’re not a terrorist, wannabe ‘jihadi bride’ – planning on running off to Syria to find your ISIS prince in blood-stained camouflage. It almost made me think I should buy one, it might make walking through security checks at airports a little easier. I could get on a train without being accosted by a fully uniformed soldier, drunkenly telling me he joined the army to “kill dirty Muslims”.
I also take issue with the fact that a symbol of my religion is being appropriated as a marketing tool for empire. My hijab is a visual sign of my religiosity and devotion to Allah and not a walking talking billboard on which to showcase my patriotism and undying loyalty to Britain. No other religious group is pressured to prove their allegiance in the same way. Somehow I don’t think we will be seeing a budding Jewish designer marketing a poppy kippa anytime soon.
Refusing to wear the poppy is not an ‘extremist Muslim’ stance; it is an ideological position based on anti-war sentiment. Nobody would accuse a white person of extremism for refusing to wear one. Every year we get the same old argument about the significance of the poppy. Some argue that the poppy does not represent war and patriotism but rather commemorates those servicemen who lost their lives in the world wars. Whilst many, non-Muslims and Muslims alike, choose not to wear the poppy because they feel it has been appropriated by politicians and warmongers to celebrate militarism.
There has been a noticeable push by the military, the government and some Muslim groups to tell Muslims in Britain about how our brave forefathers laid down their lives for this country; preaching that we should be thoroughly ashamed of ourselves for not sacrificing ourselves in a similar vein. After all, we have a long history of being used as cannon fodder by our imperial masters, why stop now? It must be the rise of ‘Radical Islam’, we have all become ‘radical extremists’. Our grandfathers didn’t have this ‘problem’. They were proud of their subservience!
I am a prime target for these initiatives, coming from a ‘Martial Race’ as I do. My great, great grandfather was awarded an ‘order of merit’ and given title of ‘Subedar Major’ for his ‘bravery’ during the first world war. However, the fact that he was probably fighting on the Mesopotamian campaign against the Muslim Ottoman empire, doesn’t exactly fill me with ecstatic pride. It actually makes me a bit nauseous to think about what ‘brave’ act he must have carried out to be given the highest military award in the land.
But it is my grandfather’s legacy that really makes me reject this idea that I should celebrate these men’s sacrifices. He was one of the 2.5 million Indian men that left British India to fight for the Allied powers during the second world war. Part of the Western Desert Campaign, he was stationed in Libya when he was captured by Italian forces in 1941, only to spend the next few years as a prisoner of war in German/Italian prison camps with none of his family aware of his whereabouts during the entire time. British Army officials in Delhi didn’t deem it necessary to provide them with any information. His family thought they were seeing a ghost when he walked back into the village nearly 5 years later.
Only a few decades after the war this man, who survived bombings, ground invasions and prison camps for the sake of Britain, arrived on these shores to be met with racial hostility and discrimination that he would have to endure until he went to his grave. He lived in the UK through the speech by Enoch Powell, and groups like the National Front telling him to “go back where he came from.” The sad fact is that our forefathers laid down their lives for this country and they were rewarded with nothing but humiliation and degradation. Things haven’t changed much, the rise of Islamophobia means their grandchildren and great grandchildren suffer new hues of abuse and negative stereotyping.
So forgive me for being a bit suspicious of this new found need to celebrate the legacy of Muslim soldiers in British wars. These men were never given the respect and honour they deserved when they were alive, so why pretend now? I see it for what it is, nothing but a cynical PR campaign to co-opt Muslim opposition to aggressive foreign policy. Perpetual war needs perpetual support and nationalism, which is perceived as somewhat lacking in the British Muslim community. The military and government hawks need to “win hearts and minds” and how better to do that than get us all walking around as human billboards advertising our undying support for war?
I don’t see an end to these types of conciliatory initiatives. What next? Why don’t I just take off my hijab full stop to prove the degree of my ‘integration’? Support every ill-conceived disastrous war that the elite establishment decides to join? Would that prove that I’m not dangerous? Maybe then I will be seen as being entitled to live here and given equal treatment.
I refuse.
My grandfather risked his life defending this country and was still shunned and told that he did not belong here. I will always be seen as the ‘other’ regardless of how much I try to fit in. That’s something that needs to be addressed by wider British society, it requires open debate and discussion — not gimmicks.
If there is one thing I am sure of, it is that given the British establishment’s never ending lust for war in Muslim lands, and the use of the poppy campaign to garner support and sympathy for the military, my grandfather and those countless other Muslim men who took part in the world wars would turn in their graves at the sight of their grandchildren wearing that hijab.
[donationbanner]
Source: www.islam21c.com
Notes:
WW1 was certainly a total waste of life on all sides. What’s even more ridiculous is that the King of England, the Kaiser and the Tzar were all cousins. However, the poppy should be respected as a symbol of the common individuals to honor them. Honor the individual, not those that forced them to fight in their royal feuds
I am a Muslim too.Alhamdulillah & I am amazed to read this aggressive extremist approach to a simple thing like poppy hijab. Trust me you would not go to hell for wearing a poppy hijab & neither would your ancestors turn in grave for such a trivial matter. Sister you have the ability to exaggerate things I must say
@nighat, sister Sofia is not extreme. May Allaah make her of those who meet Him in a pleasing state.
besides, according to whose standard is she extreme? Those same people who want you to wear the poppy headscarf? why do we have fit into their standards?
Sofia made some very valid points. Without a doubt our fathers were treated awfully despite their fathers/grandfathers fighting for this land.
Remberance day it is not a day of remembrance for “all fallen heroes,” rather it is a day to remember specifically those who died from among the “allies” during WW1.
In other words, it is a day to honour the British and French troops that died killing Muslims in a war against the Uthmani Khilafah (Ottoman Caliphate). It is a day to honour those who destroyed the Khilafah, divided our lands and our Ummah according to the Sykes-Picot Agreement, handed Palestine over to Herzl’s Zionists according to the Balfour Declaration, and crushed any semblance of independence or unity within our Ummah for the next 90 years.
Every year, Muslims are slapped in the face with this symbol of the British and French conquest over our Ummah and our Deen. We are taught to wear it with pride, to even wear Hijab with poppies on it, and celebrate the last 90 years of tyranny, death, rape, and destruction that this Ummah has suffered at the hands of the colonialists.
They speak of things like “they fought for our freedoms,” as if the Khilafah was a threat to humanity, as if humanity was saved from this evil threat.
Any Muslim that wears a poppy or recommends wearing a poppy either is unaware of the history of this Ummah, or they have simply chosen to support their slavers.
No Muslim should honour the memory of those war criminals by wearing a poppy, just as no one would honour a criminal that killed his or her mother and father.
This November 11th, remember the Muslims who died defending the Muslim lands from British and French occupation, and died trying to save the last Khilafah from destruction.
Take some time to read up on what really took place in WW1. Palestinians are still suffering til this day because this horrid war
Dear My Sister in Islam,
Perfect summary of why we, Ummah, are in our current miserable condition.
May Allah reward your knowledge of what happened from His Throne here and Hereafter. Amin.
I wish so many muslim women could have your level of thinking too.
Warmest Regards,
Ma’ssalam
JazakAllah, sister, May Allah reward you for this beautiful and convincingly articulated article: 100 years of Wars, now all the warring factions of those days are concentrating against Muslims all over the world. Besides, the money and man-power of British India has never been recognised by the colonising Empire and their European allies: all sikhs, Muslims, Hindus of the British India fought in vain except for the salaries they were getting from their Masters. Baarikallah for your effort and your perception.
As much I agree with your stance not to wear Poppy Hijab I have no objection to those sisters wearing it. With islamophobia in full swing I can even go a bit further and say that this is a welcome gesture for once showing Muslims in good light.
Never will the Jews nor the Christians be pleased with you (O Muhammad Peace be upon him ) till you follow their religion. Say: “Verily, the Guidance of Allah (i.e. Islamic Monotheism) that is the (only) Guidance. And if you (O Muhammad Peace be upon him ) were to follow their (Jews and Christians) desires after what you have received of Knowledge (i.e. the Quran), then you would have against Allah neither any Wali (protector or guardian) nor any helper.
I love you for the sake of Allah sister.Thanks for this piece; totally agree with you!
Well at least the sisters in the UK have started to grow a spine. A pitty the brothers are so busy cowering like women.
Ten years ago this attitude would have been more helpful but now its just a sign of how far the UK muslims have fallen.
MashAllah sister Sofia, if only the community had that much backbone.
An excellent article sister!! May Allah reward you & protect the Muslims from the plans & ploys of those who wish to dilute our Deen. Ameen
Some excellent points metioned in this article. We are forever becoming apologists and soo many Muslims out there feel there is a need to jump on the bandwagon!
Well put Sofia, May Allah reward you…..I agree with you, and if I was in the UK I would refuse to buy or wear a poppy hijab.
I totally agree with you. When I saw the item on the news I initially thought that’s nice but then asked myself why we should pander to something that is so ostentatious and vulgar. It’s like wear this and we see you as ok to the outside world. Cringeworthy comes to mind.
I agree 100%. Your article is excellent in that it articulates precisely what the Islamic perspective is on whether to wear a poppy hijab. My grandfather was in the merchant navy protecting commercial activity during the war but he was met with hostility when he landed in Liverpool and decided to stay in England. Why should Muslims celebrate the killing of Humans for the Interest of Bankers like Roth child who made billions through human suffering. Excellent work