• Home
  • Read
    • Products
      • Featured Articles
      • News Views
      • Magazines ↗
    • Themes
      • Current Affairs
      • Politics
      • History
      • Counter Terrorism
      • Islamophobia
      • Tarbiya
    • Seasons
      • Ashura
      • Christmas
      • Dhul Hijjah
      • Sha’ban
      • Mawlid
      • New Year
      • Ramadan
  • Watch
    • Unscripted
    • Big Discussions
    • Online Masjid ↗
  • Campaigns
    • Stand4Uyghurs ↗
    • In Their Shoes ↗
  • Shop ↗
  • Prayer Times
  • Donate
  • More
    • About Us
    • Advertise your Business
    • Contact Us
    • Jobs
    • Submit an Article
    • Subscribe
    • Write
Facebook Twitter Instagram YouTube WhatsApp Telegram
Islam21c
  • Home
  • Read
    • Products
      • Featured Articles
      • News Views
      • Magazines ↗
    • Themes
      • Current Affairs
      • Politics
      • History
      • Counter Terrorism
      • Islamophobia
      • Tarbiya
    • Seasons
      • Ashura
      • Christmas
      • Dhul Hijjah
      • Sha’ban
      • Mawlid
      • New Year
      • Ramadan
  • Watch
    • Unscripted
    • Big Discussions
    • Online Masjid ↗
  • Campaigns
    • Stand4Uyghurs ↗
    • In Their Shoes ↗
  • Shop ↗
  • Prayer Times
  • Donate
  • More
    • About Us
    • Advertise your Business
    • Contact Us
    • Jobs
    • Submit an Article
    • Subscribe
    • Write
Islam21c
Home»News»The Fake Fatwa That Went Viral

The Fake Fatwa That Went Viral

News By Editor15/02/20171 Comment3 Mins Read

Recently an Egyptian news site published a report quoting an Azhari scholar, Khaled Al Gendy, saying “that drinking liquor without getting drunk is not sinful.”[1]

It was based on a television panel discussion where four scholars—one from each school of law—was discussing the issue of ‘khamr’ from the perspectives of their respective Imāms.


Also read:

Famous story of German new years’ sexual assault by refugees was “completely made up”


  • Helps complete development and release our brand new website where all the above happens
  • Helps run National Khutbah days with 100s of Imams reaching 100,000s on Jummah highlighting social issues
  • Helps produce Unscripted podcast shows with global influential figures tackling todays challenges
  • Helps produce Unscripted podcast shows with global influential scholars and activists tackling today's challenges
  • Helps research featured articles by leading scholars/activists offering guidance and solutions
  • Helps write NewsViews articles setting our narrative to major breaking stories
  • By proceeding, you will be added to the Islam21c mailing list. Your data is safe with us and will be protected in accordance with our data protection policy.
  • £ 0.00
  • per month
  • NOTE: Donating Zakat? Please proceed to our Zakat applicable emergency appeal here.
  • Donation Top Up

    Are you trying to increase your Rizq? Did you know by increasing your donation right now, Allah promises to give you back MUCH MORE
  • Helps write NewsViews articles setting our narrative to major breaking stories
  • Helps research featured articles by leading scholars/activists offering guidance and solutions
  • Helps produce Unscripted podcast shows with global influential scholars and activists tackling today's challenges
  • Helps produce Unscripted podcast shows with global influential figures tackling todays challenges
  • Helps run National Khutbah days with 100s of Imams reaching 100,000s on Jummah highlighting social issues
  • Helps complete development and release our brand new website where all the above happens




To their credit, the news site posted a link to the 30-minute-long discussion,[2] however upon listening to the actual discussion it is clear that Al Gendy’s words were seriously misunderstood and misrepresented.

Before we correct the misrepresentation, it is pertinent to note that the inaccurate news article has received within two days of posting over 34,000 shares, whist the YouTube video it links to has just over 8,000 views in total. We are reminded of the age-old adage,

“A lie is half way around the world by the time the truth has its boots on;”

and the command from beyond the heavens,

يَا أَيُّهَا الَّذِينَ آمَنُوا إِن جَاءَكُمْ فَاسِقٌ بِنَبَإٍ فَتَبَيَّنُوا أَن تُصِيبُوا قَوْمًا بِجَهَالَةٍ فَتُصْبِحُوا عَلَىٰ مَا فَعَلْتُمْ نَادِمِينَ

“O you who have believed, if there comes to you a disobedient one with information, investigate, lest you harm a people out of ignorance and become, over what you have done, regretful.”[3]

Countless others have been sharing such “news” and criticising Al Gendy for the words attributed to him. Cynicism aside, whatever the intention of the people who created and spread the false news, it is undoubtable that among the consequences of sensationalist misrepresenting of Muslim scholars is the undermining of the Islamic scholarly community—an aim at the forefront of many powerful “deformist” agendas most notably that of Sisi himself.[4]

Setting the record straight

This is not to defend any personality but to clarify the truth of the matter. The news site quoted the scholar as saying,

“If the same alcoholic drink was consumed by one person without getting drunk, it is not haram, while being consumed by another person to drunkenness makes it haram [for this person].”

However, it is clear from the actual conversation he was having, that he was talking about what constitutes an impermissible drink in the first place, in the Sharī’a. A more suitable translation of his words would be,

“If a drink cannot intoxicate a person in any [humanly consumable] amount, then that is not haram in the first place (in fact it is not “khamr”). But if that same drink may intoxicate someone else [in a humanly consumable amount], then even a small amount of that drink is impermissible for him.”

He explicitly affirmed the principle, taken from a hadith,[5] that “whatever intoxicates in larger amounts is harām even in small amounts.” He also stated that the drinker is sinful for any effect of intoxication even if it is not complete intoxication.

The panellists also discussed the opinions surrounding intoxicants fermented from other than dates and barley, but these were surrounding whether or not the hadd punishment for drinking khamr would be applied to it. Nowhere did they say, as is claimed, that drinking something that has the ability to intoxicate you in large amounts is permissible in small amounts—as people would have understood from reading the article.


Source: www.islam21c.com

Notes:

[1] https://egyptianstreets.com/2017/02/13/drinking-liquor-without-getting-drunk-not-sinful-islamic-scholar/

[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9FWVaHxdn84

[3] Al-Qur’ān 49:6

[4] https://www.islam21c.com/politics/war-on-terror-2-0-openly-a-global-war-on-islam/

[5] Ahmad, al-Nasa’i, Tirmidhi, Ibn Majah.

Editor

Share. Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email Telegram WhatsApp
Previous ArticleAbandoning a two-state solution for an apartheid state
Next Article Famous story of German new years’ sexual assault by refugees was “completely made up”

Related Posts

Condolences on the passing of Shaykh Mahmud Effendi (1929-2022)

24/06/2022

Mohamed Morsi: Remembering the Egyptian President three years on

17/06/2022

Historic Partnership for Muslims in Cricket Between ECB & Nujum Sports

14/06/2022

Lady of Heaven: how should Muslims respond? 

10/06/2022

Johnny Depp and the Power of Truth

05/06/2022

“Death to Arabs”: Jewish ultra-nationalists storm Al-Aqsa ahead of Zionist march

29/05/2022
View 1 Comment

1 Comment

  1. Mostafa on 23/02/2017 7:56 pm

    Asalamu alaykum wa rahmatullah. Thank you for this article. I wanted to mention an important point, that Shaykh Khalid actually replied directly to this accusation. See: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_ZE3SMrjoWI&t=1010s .

    Reply

Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

Editor
Islam21c
Facebook Twitter Instagram YouTube Telegram
© 2022 Islam21c.com | All rights reserved

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.