Updates
Home / Current Affairs / Post Election Analysis: now the real work starts

Post Election Analysis: now the real work starts

Post Election Analysis: now the real work starts

England lost, Scotland won

Upon seeing the blued England on the election result maps, many have been covering a sense of woe with jokes about moving to Scotland. On first impression it seems like the politics of hysterical terror-alert fears and immigrant-bashing has won swathes of converts and pushed England and Wales to the right. However, upon further analysis of the results, things do not look quite as bleak.

Overall the Conservative party gained a razor sharp majority of 12 seats, meaning they only got six more than the minimum 325 needed to win—apparently the smallest majority ever—giving them 331 seats in the House of Commons. Most of its gains came from ex-Liberal Democrat constituencies in England and Wales. Labour lost a staggering 40 seats in Scotland to the Scottish National Party (SNP), and gained seven London constituencies among over a dozen others, giving them a total of 232 seats in the Commons. All of the constituencies where Muslims were more than 20% of the population were kept by Labour with a larger margin than in 2010. The Greens and UKIP both got one seat each.

The actual numbers of votes is where it gets interesting. Perhaps the most stark indication of the UK’s antiquated electoral system is that UKIP received 3,881,129 votes in total yet only got one seat, whilst the SNP were given 1,454,436 votes yet won 56 seats. For those who are worried about England shifting towards the right, however, this brings some consolation. If we compare those that voted for the more left-of-centre parties (Labour, Lib Dems and Greens) in England compared to the right wing parties (Conservatives and UKIP) we see only a 44%/56% split, respectively. If we bear in mind that in England the voter turnout was 65.9%, it gives us some hope.

What is so bad about a Tory win?

During their campaigning, the Tories noticeably steered clear of Muslims, instead focussing on Hindu, Sikh and Jewish minorities. Peter Oborne went so far as to say that the “Conservative Party has deliberately turned its back on British Muslims.”[1] The fact that the Tories were able to win without the “Muslim vote” has worried some Muslim commentators who believe that this will inevitably lead to more disengagement and further alienation.

The sensationalised fears of so-called “Islamic extremism” were at the front of prominent conservatives’ campaigns, with Theresa May scaring people further by telling them that a hung parliament would have made Britain vulnerable to a terrorist attack.[2] To add insult to injury her reasoning was that a hung parliament would not be able to pass anti-terror laws to give more powers to MI5 and GCHQ! This was only weeks after her infamous speech warning the wrong types of Muslims that a Conservative government would extend banning orders and investigate “Sharia courts”.[3] However her Labour counterpart Yvette Cooper as usual took her “Shadow Home Secretary” title too literally, mimicking Theresa in trying to score political points with terror;[4] based on the common irrational, jingoistic rhetoric in exchange for rational, empirical evidence-based approaches to the perceived problem of “terrorism”.[5]

The future of society

Muslims are not the only ones afraid of what is to come. Moments after the Tories’ victory was announced there were “demonstrations” (which looked more like riots [6]) outside Whitehall with 15 arrested. Many protests against the ideological austerity plans have been planned for the coming weeks.[7] Many with disabilities or on lower incomes have been calling into radio stations, sometimes in tears,[8] claiming they are actually afraid of what is going to happen to their or their loved ones’ financial assistance.

The debate on austerity—separating ideology from empirical economic data—is raging throughout Europe. All eyes have been on the debate between anti-austerity party Syriza, which won the Greece elections earlier this year, and the European Commission. The seismic success of the anti-austerity SNP in the UK is a chance for the fight within the UK against insulating the wealthy and powerful.

Perhaps the most unbelievable and terrifying result after the election was the appointment of the neocon ideologue, Michael Gove as Justice Secretary![9] Cameron has tasked the former Education Secretary who unremorsefully alienated and infuriated literally millions, namely teachers, and of course Muslims during the Trojan Hoax scandal,[10] to take care of perhaps one of the most unpopular tasks of the new government. He has already begun preparing the pledged repeal of the Human Rights Act,[11] something that is well known to be incompatible with neoconservative ideology.[12] The threat this poses is multiplied by the decapitation of the main opposition party, which is now occupied with the search for a new leader. The Conservative Government’s attempts to strip away the Human Rights Act 1998 reminds me of a saying from Shaykhul Islam, Ibn Taymiyyah (Rahimahullah) who said:

“Civilisation is rooted in justice, and the consequences of oppression are devastating. Therefore, it is said that Allah aids the just state even if it is non-Muslim, yet withholds His help from the oppressive state even if it is Muslim”

The British establishment would do well to listen to the advise of Ibn Taymiyyah because it’s the erosion of rights such as this which will ultimately inevitably lead to Allah withholding His help and when that happens, then know the decline of the state is ever near.

No despair

Many from the general public who are concerned with social justice, welfare and inclusion, have expressed sadness and even despair at the last few days’ events. Some have called the influence of big businesses and the security services on the election a “subversion of democracy”,[13] whilst others have said they are “ashamed to belong to a country that has clearly identified itself as insular, self-absorbed and apparently caring so little for the most vulnerable people among us.”[14]

However, for the Muslims, I cannot help but feel a sense of excitement and opportunity because we recognise the simple fact that Allāh (subḥānahu wa taʿālā) has created this life as a test. When any change happens, especially something as tectonic as this, we should be eager to rise to the challenges and identify the opportunities to come closer to Allāh. It is sad to see many Muslims despairing about the problems of the system – “what good did voting do?” – as though they were expecting that an ʿUmar b. al-Khattāb could have been elected as Prime Minister. It is clear that there are problems and many challenges, but these are all opportunities for us.

The election is only a small part of activism; now the real works starts. The Labour and Lib Dem parties are both going to be searching for new leaders — are we going to play any part in trying to influence that? Internally, Labour are having a conversation about what direction to move in. Although all the evidence points to them having to move to the left to regain the disillusioned social justice and inclusion voters, there are indeed ideologically neoconservative voices calling for a more right-wing, Blairite move.  With such a slim majority on the Tory benches, more marginal voices may be amplified, too.  These are all opportunities for us.

This is why, regardless of who got elected, the real politics will start now, and it does look exciting indeed. We will, inshāAllāh, be filling the gaps in knowledge and understanding by facilitating a discourse with experts, activists and thinkers to capitalise on the opportunities to come. Before the election we published an article laying the foundations for a low-effort, widespread lobbying movement: Rise of the Keyboard Army.[15] Get in touch by emailing [email protected] to register your interest and become part of the movement.

Finally, we must not forget that almost 4 million people did vote for a party that is openly hostile to Muslims, and only Allāh knows how many more are to the right of the Tory party. Xenophobia is on the rise, which thrives on ignorance and the unknown. Muslims need to work particularly hard to bridge the gap of knowledge and understanding between us and the general masses. This is because real-life educational experiences and relationships does to xenophobia and Islamophobia what a ray of light does to a dark room; it illuminates.

Rise of the Keyboard Army | A new era of Muslim political activism

Source: www.islam21c.com

Notes:

[1] http://www.middleeasteye.net/columns/turning-its-back-muslims-britains-conservatives-take-major-gamble-1352715168#sthash.r65MuUZN.dpuf

[2] http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3063425/Vote-deadlock-leave-exposed-terror-threat-says-Home-secretary-says-new-legislation-urgently-needed-update-MI5-GCHQ-s-power.html

[3] http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/terrorism-in-the-uk/11488942/Theresa-May-tells-Islamist-extremists-The-game-is-up.html

[4] http://www.standard.co.uk/news/politics/cooper-terror-suspects-face-being-forced-out-of-capital-if-labour-win-10215096.html

[5] https://www.islam21c.com/politics/new-study-extremism-does-not-cause-terrorism-2/

[6] http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/election-2015-32678518

[7] http://www.thepeoplesassembly.org.uk/

[8] http://www.lbc.co.uk/listen-a-carer-weeps-over-tory-cut-fears-109470

[9] http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2015/may/10/conservatives-to-push-forward-on-manifesto-and-scrap-human-rights-act

[10] https://www.islam21c.com/category/special/trojan-hoax/

[11] http://www.mirror.co.uk/usvsth3m/13-basic-rights-youre-going-5673763

[12] https://coolnessofhind.wordpress.com/2014/10/08/human-rights-and-justice-understanding-the-neoconservative-threat/

[13] https:[email protected][email protected]aac4

[14] http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/belief/2015/may/08/democracy-a-religion-that-has-failed-the-poor

[15] https://www.islam21c.com/politics/rise-of-the-keyboard-army/

About Dr Salman Butt

Salman studied Biochemistry at Imperial College London followed by a PhD in Chemical Biology, carrying out research into photosynthesis. During his years at university he became involved in Islamic society da'wah and activism, and general Muslim community projects. He is the Chief Editor and a regular contributor at Islam21c, and also has a blog on the Huffington Post.

9 comments

  1. Is the moderator ever going to approve my comment made on 12/05/2015 ?

    • Probably not.
      Moderators, like God, move in mysterious ways their wonders to perform. Among my posts still awaiting moderation is one quoting the great historian Edward Gibbon’s summary of ST. George’s career. I posted a hint about this, which was deemed acceptable for publication, even though without the original post it is meaningless.

  2. “All of the constituencies where Muslims were more than 20% of the population were kept by Labour with a larger margin than in 2010.”

    The party one votes for is only the first half of the story, where the person is located in Britain is the second half. The majority (I estimate around 80%) of Muslims in England live in either safe, or reliable except in the case of a 1983 style Conservative landslide, Labour constituencies. Therefore Muslims who live in these constituencies need to learn that voting Labour will NOT get you a Labour government. Labour can stack up over 90% of votes in constituencies like Birmingham Hall Green or Blackburn but it won’t influence the outcome of the election any more than if they managed to win the same constituencies on just 40% of the vote. If Labour is to form a majority in the Commons then they have to win a sufficient number of marginal constituencies in the suburbs and shires where very few Muslims live. To win these marginal constituencies they have to appease a sufficiently high number of middle Englanders which they utterly failed to do so this year.

    Far too many Muslims have fallen into a trap of thinking that votes are all piled up nationally and the party with the most votes wins the election. Nothing could be further from the truth.

    “During their campaigning, the Tories noticeably steered clear of Muslims, instead focussing on Hindu, Sikh and Jewish minorities.”

    Because they realised that very few Muslims live in the marginal constituencies they needed to win the election but an increasing number of Hindus and Sikhs have moved into such constituencies in recent times. The majority of Muslims live in constituencies low down on the Conservative Party’s target list that they are only putting in paper candidates for.

    “The Labour and Lib Dem parties are both going to be searching for new leaders — are we going to play any part in trying to influence that?”

    The Lib-Dems are probably smashed beyond repair and will never recover as the force that they were just a few years ago. Therefore, why should anybody, Muslims being no exception, be concerned who is the leader of the Lib-Dems (and it will be one of their seven other MPs) if it’s now largely an irrelevant party facing oblivion? In nearly half of all constituencies the Lib-Dems were beaten by the Green Party, and I expect that the Greens will have replaced the Lib-Dems as the secular radical left of centre political force in England in a few years time. Already membership of the Greens has topped the 60,000 mark and is now higher than that of the Lib-Dems which is set to plummet in the near future.

    “Internally, Labour are having a conversation about what direction to move in. Although all the evidence points to them having to move to the left to regain the disillusioned social justice and inclusion voters, there are indeed ideologically neoconservative voices calling for a more right-wing, Blairite move.”

    I expect that civil war will break out in Labour over the economic issue regardless of who they pick as leader. Another complicating factor is that analysis of the election results shows that a high proportion of UKIP votes have come from white working class English people who traditionally would have voted Labour. This is a sign that if Labour wants to win back these UKIP voters then they have no choice except be patriotic, pro-British, tough on multiculturalism, and drastically cut immigration. If instead Labour decides to pander to immigrants, foreigners, and Muslims then expect UKIP to win most of their white working class English heartland constituencies, like Rotherham and Doncaster, in 2020 just like the SNP won their Scottish constituencies this year.

    “Finally, we must not forget that almost 4 million people did vote for a party that is openly hostile to Muslims”

    If it’s UKIP you are referring to then take into account that they do have Muslim members, election candidates, and that many Muslims have voted UKIP. The Conservatives with Theresa May as home secretary and David Cameron who uses terminology like “draining the swamp” and goes as far as including the word Islamist in the party’s manifesto is far more hostile to Muslims than UKIP is. Just because the Conservatives aren’t racist in the traditional sense, and have more non-Muslim black and Asian members and MPs than ever before, doesn’t make them any more friendly to Muslims than it was during the years when the Monday Club was a powerful influence on party policy and its membership was almost 100% white.

  3. “Upon seeing the blued England on the election result maps, many have been covering a sense of woe with jokes about moving to Scotland”
    …yet there are over three and a half times as many muslims as a proportion of the population in England compared with Scotland, which suggests the attraction is rhetorical rather than sincere.

    • Zulfiqan Shahn

      True this. However I think the notion was actually meant to be tongue in cheek, rather than people seriously upping sticks and moving. Just like whenever people talk about university fees or laws against gazumping, etc etc.

  4. For some reason we muslims refuse to do our own souls searching!! I was brought up my father upon the poignant statement by the great Imam Ibn Taymiyah, with advice to apply this not remotely to a state, but in personal life and family life more importantly. Today muslims are unjust to each other, within their families, within their societies, and of course, quite obviously, within their States. Put ourselves in the shoes of non muslims – who would want to touch muslims even with a six foot pole!! Even muslims are wary of muslims these days!! By the way, in Isleworth in London, the Conservative Party Club, has allowed the use of its premises for Friday prayers, Taraweeh prayers, and evening use, for muslims, unreservedly!! This been ongoing for long time! I have attended prayers there myself. Any such example comes to mind from Labour or any other party?? Allah supports the State in UK because of justice and human rights which are enshrined here, as opposed to any Islamic state anywhere where there is little justice!! Ibn Taymiyah was right.

  5. Naved Siddiqi

    Whilst I think it is positive that continued engagement with civic issues and policies is seen as an ongoing exercise, I think it is a mistake to think about a bloc Muslim position, and to assume that Muslims are leftist Labour (most Muslim areas are actually low income areas), or to conclude that the Conservative Party is “openly hostile to Muslims” (it is rightly concerned with national security issues – protection of the state and its citizens is the first responsibility of Government).

    Muslims need to approach politics as citizens OF, not as a bloc that is apart and within. Muslim political choices will change and broaden organically.

    I can fully understand the dismay at the results in quarters.

    • Mister Chaudhri

      Salaam Naved. I believe part of the conclusion stating “almost 4 million people did vote for a party that is openly hostile to Muslims” is referring to UKIP, not the Tories as you’ve mistakenly mentioned. Also I don’t think anywhere in there article it was assumed that “Muslims are leftist labour”. Please correct me if I’m wrong, I’m only trying to clarify 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

Verify *

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR MAILING LIST