• Home
  • News
  • Articles
  • Podcast
  • Campaigns
    • In Their Shoes
    • Stand4Uyghurs
  • Topics
    • Current Affairs
    • Education
    • Islamic Thought
    • Opinion
    • Politics
    • Spirituality
    • Women
  • More
    • About
    • Advertise
    • Contact
    • Jobs
    • Submit
    • Subscribe
    • Write
Donate
Islam21cIslam21c
  • Home
  • Articles
  • News
  • Podcast
  • Donate
Search
  • Home
  • News
  • Articles
  • Podcast
  • Campaigns
    • In Their Shoes
    • Stand4Uyghurs
  • Topics
    • Current Affairs
    • Education
    • Islamic Thought
    • Opinion
    • Politics
    • Spirituality
    • Women
  • More
    • About
    • Advertise
    • Contact
    • Jobs
    • Submit
    • Subscribe
    • Write

Stay Updated

Stay updated to receive the latest from Islam21c

Subscribe
Made by ThemeRuby using the Foxiz theme Powered by WordPress

The moral hysteria of Je suis charlie

By Editor 12/01/2015 5 Min Read
Share

Here is a thought experiment: Suppose that while the demonstrators stood solemnly at Place de la Republique the other night, holding up their pens and wearing their “je suis charlie” badges, a man stepped out in front brandishing a water pistol and wearing a badge that said “je suis cherif” (the first name of one of the two brothers who gunned down the Charlie Hebdo staff). Suppose he was carrying a placard with a cartoon depicting the editor of the magazine lying in a pool of blood, saying, “Well I’ll be a son of a gun!” or “You’ve really blown me away!” or some such witticism. How would the crowd have reacted? Would they have laughed? Would they have applauded this gesture as quintessentially French? Would they have seen this lone individual as a hero, standing up for liberty and freedom of speech? Or would they have been profoundly offended? And infuriated. And then what? Perhaps many of them would have denounced the offender, screaming imprecations at him. Some might have thrown their pens at him. One or two individuals — two brothers perhaps — might have raced towards him and (cheered on by the crowd) attacked him with their fists, smashing his head against the ground. All in the name of freedom of expression. He would have been lucky to get away with his life.

Masses of people have turned the victims of a horrific assassination (which the staff of the magazine truly are) into heroes of France and free speech. The point of the thought experiment is not to show that such people are hypocrites. Rather, it is to suggest that they don’t know their own minds. They see themselves as committed to the proposition that there are no limits to freedom of expression: no subject so sensitive, no symbol so sacrosanct, that it cannot be sent up, sneered at and parodied, consequences be damned. They call this “courage” and they think it is the defining difference between them and the killers – and not just the killers but anyone who thinks there are limits to what can be said or printed. But they too have their limits. They just don’t know it.

Continue reading at Mondoweiss here


Reactions to Charlie Hebdo

The Charlie Hebdo shootings have provoked a storm of sensationalist reactions from opportunists across the spectrum. At Islam21c we have been working hard to sift through the rhetoric and find reasoned analysis from all quarters – links are available below to read. Don’t forget to like, comment and share! To keep up with the latest articles on Islam21c.com subscribe to our mailing list here

We also direct your attention to the seminal report written by Prof. Arun Kundnani since empirically-refuted connections are being made left, right and centre, between these shootings and the shooters’ incidental ideology – read the ground-breaking report that shows that Extremism does NOT cause terrorism: A Decade Lost; Rethinking Radicalisation and Extremism

a decade lost

Also read:

  • Freedom of speech is an ideological construct by Afia Ahmed Chaudhry
  • Freedom of Speech in France: For the Powerful, By the Powerful, With the Powerful by Hassan Colone
  • We are not Charlie Sadia Habib by Islam21c
  • My first response to the Paris incident Sh Haitham Al Haddad by Islam21c
  • France Attack – the response [Video] by Dr Salman Butt
  • Charlie Hebdo Shootings – Censored Video by Storm Clouds Gathering 
  • The moral hysteria of Je sues charlie by Prof Brian Klug
  • This map shows every attack on French Muslims since Charlie Hebdo by Tell MAMA
  • Paris attack designed to shore up France’s vassal status by Dr Paul Craig Roberts
  • Charlie Hebdo and the Profiteers of Tragedy by AntiWar.com

charlie hebdo banner

Visit our dedicated page to #CharlieHebdo with all our hand-picked content here

[donationbanner]


Editor 12/01/2015 12/01/2015
Share This Article
Facebook Twitter Whatsapp Whatsapp Telegram Copy Link Print
Previous Article This map shows every attack on French Muslims since Charlie Hebdo
Next Article Charlie Hebdo Shootings – Censored Video
Leave a comment Leave a comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Welcome to the all-new Islam21c website

Related

FOSIS Urge Muslim Students to Lead a Disaffiliation Campaign Against the NUS for Institutional Islamophobia

Islamophobia Latest News News Politics

French state condemned for anti-Muslim hysteria – Rishi Sunak should take note

Islamophobia Latest News Politics

Sri Lanka Crisis: A Warning To Islamophobes Everywhere

Asia Islamophobia Latest News News Politics Sri Lanka

We Cannot Defeat Islamophobia Without Defeating Zionism 

America Europe Featured Islamophobia Middle East Netherlands Opinion Palestine Politics UK US
Show More
Facebook Twitter Youtube Instagram Telegram

© 2023 Islam21c | All rights reserved

Work with us

Whether you want to volunteer or be a part of our team, there are ways you can always make a contribution to the Muslim Ummah.

View vacancies

Stay connected!

We know how it feels to miss out on the latest breaking stories, exciting project announcements, and multimedia productions, so here is this handy box to make sure you don’t miss a thing! Signing up takes just 10 seconds.

Subscribe
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?