Trolls and Martyrdom: Je Ne Suis Pas Charlie

There is no such thing as speech so hateful or offensive it somehow “justifies” or “legitimizes” the use of violence. The right to free expression—that’s a universal. The fear of violence should not determine what one does or does not say. In an ideal world that simply would not be a consideration because a violent reaction to speech would not be allowed to occur—in the imperfect world we live in, we should strive for the standard of knowing what we say might attract violence but speaking out as though the threat did not exist. That is the essence of the virtue we call “courage,” and the staff of Charlie Hebdo displayed it and should be honored for possessing it.

Okay, is that established? I am assuming this is basic common ground for everyone in this conversation, and anyone who disagrees should simply be excluded from it. (And deliberately dragging someone who does disagree into the conversation, as USA Today did, is at best counterproductive and at worst looks like the worst kind of clickbaiting.)

Because if we’re all agreed on that: Charlie Hebdo is also a crap publication and people need to stop celebrating it and making martyrs out of its staff.

Continue reading at  The Daily Beast here

Reactions to Charlie Hebdo

The Charlie Hebdo shootings have provoked a storm of sensationalist reactions from opportunists across the spectrum. At Islam21c we have been working hard to sift through the rhetoric and find reasoned analysis from all quarters – links are available below to read. Don’t forget to like, comment and share! To keep up with the latest articles on Islam21c.com subscribe to our mailing list here

We also direct your attention to the seminal report written by Prof. Arun Kundnani since empirically-refuted connections are being made left, right and centre, between these shootings and the shooters’ incidental ideology – read the ground-breaking report that shows that Extremism does NOT cause terrorism: A Decade Lost; Rethinking Radicalisation and Extremism

Also read:

• Freedom of speech is an ideological construct by Afia Ahmed Chaudhry
• Freedom of Speech in France: For the Powerful, By the Powerful, With the Powerful by Hassan Colone
• We are not Charlie Sadia Habib by Islam21c
• My first response to the Paris incident Sh Haitham Al Haddad by Islam21c
• France Attack – the response [Video] by Dr Salman Butt
• Charlie Hebdo Shootings – Censored Video by Storm Clouds Gathering 
• The moral hysteria of Je sues charlie by Prof Brian Klug
• This map shows every attack on French Muslims since Charlie Hebdo by Tell MAMA
• Paris attack designed to shore up France’s vassal status by Dr Paul Craig Roberts
• Charlie Hebdo and the Profiteers of Tragedy by AntiWar.com

Visit our dedicated page to #CharlieHebdo with all our hand-picked content here